Readers Write: Which is worth more? A student’s life or 150 shekels?

Readers Write: Which is worth more? A student’s life or 150 shekels?

Should parents worry when they send their 18-year-old son and only child to an Israel gap year program? Perhaps you should.

Our son, Ariel Newman, died due to heat stroke seven days after getting off the airplane on Sept. 3, 2014. To this day, the Israeli government has wrongly gone out of its way to protect those responsible for Ariel’s death.

Ariel was in Israel to attend a gap-year program at Mechinat Yeud. This yeshiva, led by Rosh Yeshiva Rabbi Yaakov Shapira, was a member of MASA, an organization founded by the Prime Minister’s Office together with the Jewish Agency for Israel.

MASA brings young people from around the world to Israel to deepen their connection with the country.

On Sept. 9, only six days after Ariel arrived in Israel, the yeshiva’s program director, Joshua Ettinger, led the group of twelve young men on a two-day hike into the Judean desert.

Rabbi Naftali Rothstein, the yeshiva’s education director, was to drive the car that would bring supplies and was meant to serve as the evacuation vehicle in case of an emergency.

This two-day hike was originally scheduled for January 2015 in the winter time when the Judean desert is cooler and when the students had time to become acclimatized to their new environment.

Instead, for a reason known only to them, Ettinger and Rabbi Shapira changed the date of the hike to September 9-10, 2014.

On the second day, the hike was to go from Nachal Tzeilim to Nachal Mishmar in six hours, from 8:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. The Ministry of Education website states this hike takes 8-10 hours, should not be conducted in the summertime, and should be made only by those with intermediate to expert hiking experience.

Ettinger, with the full knowledge of Shapira, took young men out with little to no hiking experience, and made them hike in six hours what would take 8-10 hours for an expert hiker — in the summertime on the second day of a two-day hike.

When the police asked an official from the Ministry of Tourism if this was an appropriate hike for rank beginner hikers in the summertime, the official said no, it was not a reasonable hike.

Both Ettinger and Shapira published in promotional material that Ettinger was licensed by the Ministry of Tourism and was a certified medic.

Israeli law demands that tour guides of adults and foreigners be led by someone with a Ministry of Tourism tour guide license. Unfortunately, the promotional material was false. Ettinger did not have a Ministry of Tourism tour guide license and he did not have a valid medic certification.

Ariel was wearing long black nylon pants on the hike which means the heat in the lower half of his body was trapped during the two-day hike.

No one else on the hike wore long pants made out of material that trapped their body heat. Ettinger’s response as to why he allowed this was that checking clothing wasn’t his responsibility. He had complete indifference.

Since hiking is an Israeli past-time, MASA had one absolute requirement for all its members in respect to hiking: you must coordinate with a safety organization such as the Society for the Protection of Nature in Israel.

SPNI provides advice about any possible danger while hiking. Neither Ettinger nor Shapira contacted SPNI (or any other safety organization) but, if they had inquired, they would have been told on September 10, 2014 in that Judean desert area, no one should be hiking from 10:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., due to excessive heat.

These two men ignored an absolute mandate from MASA and our son is now dead because of that. What is their response? Shapira says that it was only a MASA rule and not Israeli law. Shapira’s other excuse is even more chilling. He said that paying SPNI is too expensive.

What was the cost to inquire? 150 shekels. Protecting a student’s life is not worth 150 shekels?

At lunchtime on Sept. 10, by all accounts, Ariel clearly looked beyond worn out.

He was saying all day that he couldn’t do the hike anymore and when Rothstein came with the car, Ariel cried out to Ettinger that he must be taken back because he has heat stroke and can’t go on.

Ettinger told Ariel that there’s no room in the evacuation vehicle and he doesn’t have heat stroke. “Yaaleh!” After about an additional half hour of hiking, Ariel dropped to the ground. Upon admission to Hadassah Ein Kerem hospital in Jerusalem, Ariel’s inner core body temperature was 43 degrees Celsius or 109.4 degrees Fahrenheit.

The hospital made a valiant effort to keep him alive but to no avail. The hospital’s medical report stated the cause of death was heat stroke and that, after multiple testing while still alive, Ariel’s heart was fine.

In August 2017, we meet Natan Bozna, the police commander of the entire Negev Region. Looking at the circumstances of Ariel’s death, he made it clear he thought this was negligent homicide and told us the investigation up to that point was incomplete.

One example is the Arad police never even attempted to interrogate Rothstein, the driver of the evacuation vehicle, and still have not to this day. Bozna created a new task force to uncover all relevant evidence and testimony in both the US and Israel.

Are you ready for what happened next? The State Attorney’s Office then ordered Natan Bozna to stand down and conduct merely a few trivial tasks that would have no real bearing on the case.

Compare Ariel’s death to an incident where ten Israeli kids on a formal Mechina pre-military program were negligently killed in April 2018.

Those responsible were immediately arrested. If the prosecutors had carried out their job properly — they still can! — and prosecuted the two men responsible for our son’s death, it would have sent a powerful signal to all hike leaders to take safety much more seriously. And yet, even after those ten kids were killed, the prosecutors continue to do everything in their power to ensure that there will never be justice in our case.

What has Bagatz, the Israel Supreme Court, done since we filed our petition on May 1, 2018? Ignored everything. They automatically deferred to the prosecutors and absurdly claimed that the investigation was comprehensive and thorough.

The facts as laid out above, and as so powerfully displayed in Channel 10 TV’s very recent ten-minute expose broadcast, reveal that the prosecutors have not performed their job in a professional unbiased manner. Bagatz has not yet issued their final ruling but their deference to the prosecutors, in this case, is highly questionable.

Why are Ettinger and Shapira still being protected with all the might of the Israeli government?

Bagatz still has time to look into this and demand that justice be done. We have been grieving most terribly every day for over four years and believe Israel can and must do better to alleviate our suffering. “Justice, justice you shall pursue so you will live and take possession of the land that the Lord your God is giving you. (Deuteronomy 16:20)”


Mark Newman

Great Neck

Mark is married to Ellen Newman and together they were blessed with raising Ariel Yitzchak a”h for 18 years in Great Neck to love Judaism and Israel.  Mark has worked professionally for almost three decades in the US Federal government as a civil law enforcement officer.

No posts to display


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here