Readers Write: National Review column distorts Great Neck elections

1
Readers Write: National Review column distorts Great Neck elections
May 2023 issue of the National Review

In a column published in National Review (“School-Board Candidates Avoid Hard Truths for the Sake of Palatability,” 5/16), Sahar Tartak discusses recent elections in her Long Island hometown.

Though she does not specify the town, it’s clear enough to those who live here that Ms. Tartak is talking about Great Neck.

Her main contention is that “Parents should be aware of what their board of education candidates really stand for”—but Ms. Tartak misrepresents the situation here in Great Neck, presenting a distorted view of what her own preferred candidates stand for.

Some facts to consider:

Ms. Tartak suggests that a certain candidate in last year’s Board election was unfairly labeled as “a disruptive right-wing extremist.”

She is clearly referring to Emil Hakimi, who unsuccessfully ran against incumbent Donna Peirez. But “disruptive right-wing extremist” is not just a label or epithet; it is an accurate description of Mr. Hakimi, who has waged a relentless campaign of harassment and misrepresentations up to and including falsely accusing his neighbors of being pedophiles.

During his own election campaign, as well as subsequent campaigns over the last year, Mr. Hakimi has continually hurled QAnon-style smears, going so far as to label political opponents as “child pornography advocates.”

No matter what our political leanings, we should all agree that this type of poisonous rhetoric has no place in our public conversation.

Ms. Tartak’s view of this year’s election is equally skewed. She defends a candidate, Niloufar Tabari, who received some attention for her attacks on the award-winning young adult novel “If You Come Softly.”

Ms. Tabari claimed the book would teach our kids that “all white people are racist,” and Ms. Tartak apparently agrees, citing the book as an example of the district’s “racialized curriculum.”

But neither Ms. Tabari nor Ms. Tartak shows any sign of having actually read the book. Tartak doesn’t explain what about the book is supposed to be anti-white; instead of citing anything from the book itself, she merely links to an online plot summary — the equivalent of citing SparkNotes. The summary indicates that the book is a tender love story between a black boy and a Jewish girl. What in the world is anti-white about that?

Ms. Tartak is surely right about one thing, at least: it is vitally important for parents to be aware of what these candidates “really stand for.” We must keep raising awareness regarding these attacks on literature—and the scorched-earth tactics of the extreme right—and continue to elect qualified, intelligent candidates who trust educators and treat their neighbors with respect.

Danny Pitt Stoller

Great Neck

No posts to display

1 COMMENT

  1. Dear Danny,
    It is so typical today for so many to find faults and flaws in candidates and everyone else. The better path to take is to offer constructive criticism for making greater strides for improvements in all our educational and political systems.
    The real problem is always that “BAD NEWS” sells papers and “GOOD NEWS” GETS BURIED INSIDE ALL THE PAPERS AND THE NET!
    MANY POLITICIANS NO LONGER WORK FOR US. FOR WHEN THEY WANT A RAISE, THEY JUST GO TO CONGRESS AND RAISE THEIR SALARIES. HOWEVER, WHEN THE AVERAGE OR EVEN ABOVE-AVERAGE WORKER IN THE U.S. (PRE-PANDEMIC) WANTED A RAISE, GOOD LUCK. UNFORTUNATELY, DUE TO THE PANDEMIC AND SO MANY WORKERS EITHER QUITTING THEIR JOBS OR RELOCATING, ALL OF A SUDDEN EVEN WITH THE $15 MINIMUM WAGE LEGALLY AVAILABLE, SOME COMPANIES ARE PAYING MORE JUST TO GET A DECENT EMPLOYEE AND TO THAT END THEY ARE NOT COMING SO FAST ANYMORE. WE HAVE LOST 182,000 PEOPLE IN NYS TO OTHER STATES AND HAVE HAD A NET LOSS EVERY YEAR FOR THE LAST 10 YEARS! GOVERNOR CUOMO’S NO INCOME OR REAL ESTATE TAXES FOR 10 YEARS PLAN WAS A TOTAL FAILURE AS 140 MILLION DOLLARS OF TAXPAYER MONIES WAS THROWN OUT THE WINDOW ON WASTED ADVERTISING AND PROMOTIONS. NEW YORK HAS BECOME WAY TOO EXPENSIVE FOR MILLENNIALS AND GENZS AND WE HAVE LOST A HUGE AMOUNT OF TALENT. WHEN YOU GET TIME, READ MY NEWEST COLUMN ONLINE TODAY AND/OR PICK UP THE GN NEWS ON THURSDAY AFTERNOON AT THE GN DINER ON BOND AND GRACE AVE.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here